LAMB Casting: On the Waterfront (Results)

by AndrewEncore · August 13, 2012 · Lamb Casting · 3 Comments

Andrew here, FINALLY with the results of the last LAMB Casting entry. I’ll admit, a part of me kept holding off the closing of the polls hoping there’d be a last minute surge, but from the get-go your votes were all headed in one particular direction. I’d like to salute all six bloggers for their inspired re-casting take on Eliza Kazan’s On the Waterfront.

Let’s take a look at what the line-up was.

Craig / Big Thoughts of a Small Mind

ARMIE HAMMER (Terry); GRETA GERWIG (Edie); JEREMY RENNER (Johnny Friendly); EWAN MCGREGOR (Father Barry); BENJAMIN WALKER (Charley)

Standout: Ewan McGregor as Father Barry. Surely, McGregor is younger than Malden was playing Father Barry in 1954 but it’s an inspired decision by Craig since McGregor’s inherently warm screen cadence would be a fine surrogate for the no-nonsense wisdom of the film’s most moralistic character.

Eric / The Movie Waffler

TOM HARDY (Terry); JESSICA CHASTAIN (Edie); PAUL GIAMATTI (Johnny Friendly); JOHN C. REILLY (Father Barry); PHILIP SEYMOUR HOFFMAN (Charley)

Standout: Jessica Chastain as Edie. As you’ll see below half of you got stricken with the Hardy/Chastain idea, but it’s impossible to fault the choice. I’m especially interested in the idea of Chastain. For, even though she might be just a bit too mature for Edie’s naiveté she’d nail the tenderness of this reluctant love interest grieving her dead brother.

Shane / Film Actually
TOM HARDY (Terry); JESSICA CHASTAIN (Edie); WOODY HARRELSON (Johnny Friendly); EDWARD NORTON (Father Barry); JAKE GYLLENHAAL (Charley)

Standout: Woody Harrelson as Johnny Friendly. The charming menacing nature of Cobb’s performance is something difficult to replicate and great kudos to Shane for choosing Harrelson who at his best (The People vs Larry Flynt; Rampart; The Messenger) has those qualities in spades.

Chip / Tips from Chip

TOM HARDY (Terry); JESSICA CHASTAIN (Edie); RUSSELL CROWE (Johnny Friendly); TOM HANKS (Father Barry); COLIN FARRELL (Charley)

Standout: Colin Farrell as Charley. Of the five main (all Oscar nominated) roles, Charley is the most problematic mostly because it’s something a thankless role. It requires an actor immediately magnetic enough to watch, someone who could make that car-scene with Terry work. Farrell hasn’t had quite enough opportunities to show his range as often as I’d like, but when he does it’s proof he’d do fine in a performance like this.

Walter / The Silver Screening Room

JOSEPH GORDON-LEVITT (Terry); SCARLET JOHANSSON (Edie); RUSSELL CROWE (Johnny Friendly); MARK RUFFALO (Father Barry); SAM ROCKWELL (Charley)

Standout: Scarlett Johansson as Edie. Sometimes I feel alone when it comes to my appreciation for Scarlett Johansson, but at this point it’s futile to argue. Admittedly, Johansson does particularly well when forced to use her sexuality to best effect (see: Match Point) so I’d be intrigued to see how she uses her natural qualities to enhance the character if Edie who is one of those anomalous ingénues who is both naïve and defiant.

Anna / Defiant Success

JAKE GYLLENHAAL (Terry); MICHELLE WILLIAMS (Edie); MATT DAMON (Johnny Friendly); PETER SARSGAARD (Father Barry); MICHAEL FASSBENDER (Charley)

Standout: Michelle Williams as Edie. What can I say? You guys really impressed me with your choices for the women. The thing is, Williams has been playing such older roles of late her playing Edie might seem the slightest bit unlikely but she evokes that same willowy beauty of Saint and would almost certainly manage to nail the sad tenderness of the character.

Despite these six great choices the votes were firmly for a particularly cast who raked in half of the votes. Before I announce the winner, congrats to Chip for being the runner up this time around. The ultimate winner, with a landslide victory, was Eric from The Movie Waffler, one of the three Hardy/Chastain casts. Congrats, James!

Tags:

3 Responses to LAMB Casting: On the Waterfront (Results)

  1. Squasher88 says:

    Good work guys.

    Re: Karl Malden and Ewan McGregor….they would actually be about the same age, Malden just looks old. It was one of the reasons why I went with a younger person like Edward Norton in my cast.

  2. Dusty says:

    Saw the film once about a year ago. Was just trying to get myself better acquainted with Brando’s work. I don’t remember every character, but these seem to be good choices. I’m not sure about Colin Farrel though. I think of him as being too Irish to play such an American role. I’m sure the character is of Irish Decent, but that’s a bit different than just plain Irish.

    I think I would have put Phillip Seymour Hoffman in the starring role. Seems like an odd choice for a boxer, but he could do it.

  3. Er it’s actually Eric from The Movie Waffler :/

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.