In all honesty Southland Tales has just fallen out of my head. Also, as bad as it is my worst 3 are so much worse. ST was a 2/5. My 3 movies are 0.5/5 at best. It was worthy of being mentioned amongst my honourable mentions though, so I'm annoyed I forgot it for that.
But surely that would have to fall into the category of totally awesome movies!! To honest I was surprised that Jay didn't use it for his number 1, especially when its now become the film in which all others are measured against. :)